About a week ago, we (Roger and I) tried a series of three small scenarios with a theme of a quick Carnivoran raid on Federation space. We used teh Monday Knight Rules for space gaming, which features several distinct races with different weaponry and a subtle but effective way to model inertia. While fun, the result underlined the need for careful reasoning of the victory conditions in a theme based scenario.
In scenario one, a Federated convoy, using a DDL and two 'armored pursuit ships' (which is really a misnomer when you look at the armament) escorted a transport/cargo ship. The Carnivores simply needed to damage each transport to a certain level..we decided on ten hits on armor and any internal cargo or system boxes...to win. The Federated player had to exit a specific side of the map, in order to cargo to the scheduled stop.
The 'Federation' side, with stand in Aquarian ships. In the far center area are the Carnivores' ships. The large ship is the transport.
The second scenario, a few moves into the game. My photo mojo was absent this day, I apologize for the 'meh' photos. You can see how hairy the Carnivoran commander is, at least his forearms. ;-)
The carnivores had a two Destroyers and a destroyer leader. Over several turns the required number of hits were inflicted on the freighters, while the Federation ships managed to strip off a lot of Carnivoran armor but inflict little in the way of internal damage.
In scenario two the Carnivores had to get their ships home, as they eluded a Federation pursuit squadron consisting of a star bomber, DDL and a Destroyer.
In scenario three the Carnivores evaded a patrol squadron of two destroyers and an armored pursuit ship. Roger is a crafty player!
We found that the rules allowed for the build up of speed using the drift rule that allowed the Carnivores to control the length of the scenario. Even though the drift started out nominal, three hexes for all ships, the Carnivores used the tactic to make a running pass at the freighters, at 'medium range' score hits on the freighters and leave before the damage on their ships got to the point of any real danger of losing a ship , or even sustaining a lot of damage.
There were no missiles or fighters involved since the smallest category of ships were present. Back to the drawing board!